…although for the record, I drank a yummy herbal-white tea blend (Queen of Babylon blended with Rose Garden Rooibos). But I’m already getting ahead of myself.
Before the virtual latte, I met with my postdoc advisor very briefly this morning. Told him about all that’s going on right now — that I’d sent 4 pages of the discussion on one paper on which I’m the lead author, that it took me way longer to work through my revisions on another paper on which I’m the third author (I just didn’t say why it took longer than I’d planned), and that I was waiting for data for another paper. He’s pleased with the start on the discussion and will look at it closely over the next week. He was very pleased with my revisions on the other paper, and is looking forward to hearing more about the data analyses on the final paper we discussed. I also mentioned the recent rejection on the leftover paper from grad school, and he agreed that we needed to appeal it, given the bizarre circumstances. I cued him that I would be ready to talk about long-term goals and career life stuff at our next meeting in two weeks. He wanted to know if I was still thinking about writing a K99/R01 (mini-big grant that is supposed to help postdocs transition into independent researcher roles). I told him that I have thought about it and don’t see it in the cards (and I thought but didn’t say “…I have better things to do with my time right now!!!”). I told him about the phone call with my old advisor, and that I’d be at home for the rest of the day working on that, reviewing a paper for a journal, and proofreading a colleage’s grant.
I cut out of work shortly after on this basis, made a quick stop at Trader Joes’ for vegetables, salsa, etc., and then ran home. Had about a half hour to eat some lunch, make my tea and just relax a bit before calling my grad advisor (This will be an abbreviated, inarticulate version of our conversation because I need to leave for the airport relatively soon).
First, she was pretty mad about our rejection (and watch out when my grad school advisor is mad or annoyed!). She reviewed our old reviews and thinks that they are being unreasonable. From the first round of reviews, the reviewers knew about the problems they used as a basis for rejecting it this time around. Ergo, if they were going to reject it on these grounds, they should have done it during the first round of reviews instead of the third. At the very least the editor needs to get another review for us. She had some ideas for how I could structure the appeal email. If the editor won’t budge to my appeal, she’ll try again on our behalf (she’s tenured and thus can be more intimidating than me!)
Second, we chatted for a long time about what research projects I have ongoing, what I still plan to do in the near future, and what I’ve got on the backburner for the time being. In a nutshell, she thinks:
I’m being way too hard on myself for this point in my career. I’m just a postdoc, and professional development is a developmental process.
She also thinks my postdoc advisor is a jerk, although she didn’t say it directly. She did state explicitly that I was “raised” to different standards in my grad program; specifically, I was not raised to view myself as a slave at Big Rural Alma Mater, whereas I am in my lab at Large Research University. She said I need to start speaking up for myself more, and acknowledged that it’s hard for nice people to do. I need to start expecting authorship on papers I’ve contributed to, even if it’s just proofreading, as other authors are being added to my papers just for proofreading.
She also said that I was being held to unrealistic expectations in terms of where postdocs should and can reasonably publish. Any publications are good at this point in my career, and they don’t necessarily have to be in the *best* developmental psychology journals. She said I need to get stuff off the backburner and out of filing cabinets if the work’s already done, despite my current sense of overextension. She’s going to take the lead on at least one old paper that’s currently in the filing drawer.
We also talked about what type of job I’m going to be looking for next year. Her thoughts: I should apply broadly for both selected liberal-artsy jobs and at some state institutions. I want to be at a place in which drawing grant funding is a bonus, not a condition for tenure. She mentioned that I don’t need to cave to pressure to go to a Ph.D.-granting institution if I think I can do the type of research I want to do without Ph.D. students. I don’t necessarily want Ph.D. students, because in grad advisor’s words, “They’re a major time sink!” She also added, however, that it sometimes pays off, because then former students can become collaborators later on, teach old dogs new stats skills, etc. But, often times, there are good undergrads who can assist with data collection, data entry, etc. I have a feeling that this might work for me, since I think of myself more as an data analyst and wouldn’t feel right if somebody else was crunching the numbers (I don’t trust them to necessarily do it right. Yes, I’m sick).
She said that I should just start looking forward to collecting my own data, because I’ll finally be able to stop trying to make silk purses out of sow’s ears with other people’s data.
She had some specific ideas about some of my projects, how I can minimally revise them in order to get them out and under review by the time I start applying for jobs.
Last but not least, she also asked if I’d be interested in coming on to a paper off the project that supported me while I was still a grad student at Big Rural Alma Mater. They need somebody who can do structural equation modeling (a fancy type of statistical analysis that scares the living daylights out of people who don’t know it), and specifically somebody who can troubleshoot a model that’s refusing to run. I can do that, I’m used to working with these data, and the topic is in line with my research. So, it looks like I’m adding another paper to my already-full queue.
In summary, I am feeling much less discouraged following our conversation. She clearly has confidence in my abilities if she’s still willing to ask me to do papers with her. She also said that I can call her at any time if I have any additional existential crises :-S If nothing else, it sounds like she’s willing to help me keep it together so I can get out of here next year.
Her token thank-you gift has already been shipped. 