This time the article was rejected after it had been previously conditionally accepted. This particular beauty has been under review at this same journal since September 2005 and has already been revised twice. Now they reject it?!?
I sent my coauthor (A.K.A. my graduate advisor) the rejection message along with a long, convoluted email request for a “virtual latte.”
On a somewhat related note, at some point this summer, I was hoping to seek your opinion/guidance about how I should approach the job market next year. This has been on my mind for a while. I’d hoped to have a chance to talk at Big Biennial Research Conference, but it just didn’t work out, so then I thought I’d wait until after the wedding. No luck – this most recent rejection has made me think that I need to start discussing it sooner rather than later. I’m asking for your help because you’ve known me for a long time, and I trust that you can provide guidance with my best interests in mind.
My struggle to publish over the years now feels like the proverbial writing on the wall. I clearly am not cut out for this. Let’s face it… if I were a stock, shareholders would have dumped me for my disappointing performance long ago! My gut instinct is to try to return to my liberal arts roots after finishing my postdoc instead of trying for more research-oriented positions. Such repeated rejections have diminished my interest in research substantially (what’s the point of doing all this work if I can’t do it well enough to get somebody to care to publish it?). No matter how hard I work, I can’t seem to do research well enough to anticipate success in a research-oriented university of any level. Furthermore, I don’t want to play the social games that seem obligatory in order to get ahead in the field. I don’t think my research is better than anybody else’s or is going to change the world, and anybody would know I was lying if I tried to present it in those ways! I realize that the grass always seems greener on the other side of the fence, and that I haven’t always enjoyed all aspects of my teaching experiences. But such little payoff for all this hard, prolonged work on research is comparably far less enjoyable. All around, the liberal arts option is starting to feel like a better fit for my personality, worldview, neurological quirks, and Jan’s and my shared life goals.
Granted, things have been quite complicated lately because of the wedding and due to yet another medication change. I was entirely unprepared for how much extra work I have to do just to keep everything running smoothly with Hubby on the road M-F. Recently I’ve been totally worn out, the house would be a disaster if we didn’t have a cleaning service, and I know these extra personal responsibilities have affected my work. The most recent medication has helped, fortunately! A more prolific Addled is currently in the office, but it seems like way too little too late. I know I’m not at all competitive, and I don’t think I would be happy continuing with so much research after so many struggles and disappointments.
Alas I anticipate having extraordinarily little local support while seeking a new position in the coming year. In fact, I anticipate having so little support that I’ve tentatively planned to make a trip to Large Rural Alma Mater this fall to do a practice job talk to a trusted, familiar audience. Other job-seekers in my lab have received rather useless feedback on their practice job talks, mostly comments along the lines of “Make sure to use consistent colors in your slides’ figures!” This just another illustration of how my whole experience at Large Research University has been disappointing, disillusioning, and quite discouraging. It’s very clear to me that my current supervisor has been disappointed with aspects of my performance here (and granted, I haven’t told him about my ADD discovery or the ongoing struggle to find a medication that treats it properly without awful side effects). I’m very concerned about his letter of recommendation and the lack of mentoring I will receive throughout the process. I’m alarmed that most of my job-seeking colleagues have struggled to find outside employment following their time in this lab.
I know that going into this without confidence or a well-developed plan will help guarantee an undesirable employment outcome. I am very motivated to do whatever I can to get out of here and into the right sort of position for me. Part of my take on finding a job is getting experienced, trusted others’ feedback on what they think is going to be the right choice for me. Do you think that there might be a time this summer that you could please provide me with some, in order to help me start out back in the market on the right foot?
This email ended up becoming much longer than I intended, and for that I apologize profusely! All of this unleashed because of a simple rejection. I completely understand that it’s summer and that you’ll be extra busy for the next few months while you try to tie up loose ends at Large Rural Alma Mater and prepare to move to Large Rural Research University. I know that your primary obligation during this time is to your current students, research and grant collaborators, etc. Thus, please let me make explicit that I’m not asking for the level of help you provided when I was a student. I’m really just asking for your opinion on whether you think I’ve come to the right conclusion based on my evaluation of the evidence.
I had a reply and an invitation for a phone conference within minutes (my old grad advisor is a fantastic person and mentor in general, and I would have been surprised by anything other than that response). We’re chatting tomorrow at 1, between my meeting with my current boss and her meeting with a realtor. (I think I’ll go order her a bottle of wine by mail as a thank-you gift, before we even have the phone call…)
We’re also going to prepare a letter appealing the rejection. She and another faculty member from my old department at Large Rural Alma Mater think that at the very least we should get a 2nd review on the basis that the article had already been provisionally accepted.
Acknowledging that I think I want out of the research machine makes me feel strange. Part of me feels like I’m dying, but another part of me feels like I’m being set free from prison.




